52. Kelley Jo Burke, Wreck: A Very Anxious Memoir

Can a book about anxiety and family trauma be fun to read? Kelley Jo Burke’s Wreck: An Anxious Memoir says yes. Part of the reason for my enjoyment of this book is the way it plays with the conventions of memoir. Right from the outset, Burke identifies herself as a “compulsive liar” who wants to tell the truth, and Wreck is full of tall tales, memories that are contradicted by other witnesses, and multiple versions of the past. The most striking example is the way the book presents three different versions of what happened when Burke’s grandfather–an impossible man, full of piss and self-pity–asked if he could move in with his granddaughter instead of going into a home. Burke tells three stories about that event; two of them show her to be a hero in completely opposite ways, but the third and final one does not. Apparently these stories confused some reviewers, who couldn’t figure out which one actually happened, but the structure is not unlike “The Three Little Pigs” or any other European fairytale: the first thing didn’t happen, the second thing didn’t happen, but the third one did. That the structure, always. Besides, Burke admits she’s not heroic, more than once, so expecting that she would suddenly do incredible things is unreasonable.

Burke is (among other things) a playwright, and Wreck reads a little like the text for a solo performance. The voice is distinctive, a mixture of self-deprecation and braggadocio, and I can imagine parts of the text, particularly the footnotes, being delivered as asides by a skilled actor. Even the temporal shifts (from Burke’s childhood, to the period after her grandmother’s death in 1996, to what’s essentially the narrative present in 2018) could be cued with vocal cues, blocking, lighting, costumes, and props. Of course, this book is too long to actually be a solo performance, but as I read it, that’s what I was imagining.

I hadn’t planned to read Wreck, but something came up at work that encouraged me to take it off my shelf. Now my TBR schedule (I don’t really have one, but I’m pretending) is out of whack, and a couple of the books I agreed to review are sitting on my desk right now, staring at me, balefully. I’ll get to you, I will, I promise. Right after I mark these midterms.

50. Lorna Crozier, Small Beneath the Sky: A Prairie Memoir

I’ve had a copy of Lorna Crozier’s Small Beneath the Sky: A Prairie Memoir for quite a while. Like so many of my books, it has languished on a shelf somewhere, and I do mean “somewhere,” because my copy has gone missing, and I had to borrow one from the library. Still, I’ve been asked to read a graduate student’s thesis, and Small Beneath the Sky is one of the books she discusses in her paper, and I thought this was finally my chance to read it. I’m glad I did; it’s wonderful.

Small Beneath the Sky is partly a memoir about growing up in Swift Current, Saskatchewan, in the 1950s and 1960s. Hiding in that memoir is a Künstlerroman, a story about an artist’s development, although the focus is more about her family, their poverty, her father’s drinking, what a small city on the prairies was like back then. The other part of the book considers Crozier’s relationship with her parents as an adult, including grieving their deaths. Both parts are powerfully written.

Interspersed between the prose chapters of the memoir are shorter chapters of what I’m going to call (perhaps incorrectly) prose poetry. Each is identified with the title “first cause” followed by some aspect of life in this part of the world: “first cause: light,” “first cause: grass,” “first cause: sky,” “first cause: insects.” They’re beautiful, which isn’t surprising, given Crozier’s stature as a poet. The notion of a first cause, as the book points out, comes from Aristotle: it’s something that precedes the chains of cause and effect, an “immovable force” that “started it all.” The suggestion that these environmental (understood broadly) phenomena are the first causes of Crozier’s life is fascinating, since they would also be the first causes of the lives of everyone else who was born in southern Saskatchewan in the late 1940s, but her story is unique, the way theirs would be, too. So we have all of these first causes, which set in motion all of these different chains of effects and causes. That relationship between the general and the particular is a mystery. Maybe that’s Crozier’s point. It’s something I’ll be thinking about from now on.

48. Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

I read Ray Bradbury’s 1953 novel Fahrenheit 451 when I was in high school, along with everything else he wrote that was in local branch of the public library. That was a long time ago. and I only remember bits and pieces. Last spring, though, when I started thinking about what I might teach in English 100 this fall, I wondered if today’s students might get something out of this novel. The protagonist, Guy Montag, is a fireman living some 400 years (I think) in the future, except his job isn’t putting fires out: it’s burning books. You probably already know that. Fahrenheit 451 is one of those books that’s famous; its premise is known even by people who haven’t read it. I was particularly curious about how Bradbury’s vision of the future (really a vision of his present, of course) might come across in our current era of generative AI and (from what I see in classrooms) plummetting reading skills. So I put it on the syllabus. Yesterday, I decided I’d better reread the thing, so I could start thinking about how I was going to teach it.

I was pleasantly surprised at how well Fahrenheit 451 has aged. Some of the prose is overwrought, sure, but much of it effectively conveys the strange world Bradbury imagines. Montag isn’t an intellectual and his resistance to that world is primarily based in his emotions, but the novel allows a supporter of the way things are, Captain Beatty, to explain the rationale for suppressing literature, and while Bradbury clearly doesn’t want us to come away agreeing with Beatty, the argument about reading and thinking leading to conflict and a lack of social cohesion is worth considering before dismissing it. After all, there’s a lot of conflict and not a lot of cohesion or community in the terribly lonely place Bradbury imagines, and people respond to their deep unhappiness (which is mostly hidden from themselves) in a variety of self-destructive ways–and in ways that harm others, too. I wonder what my students will make of it, though. I’ll find out in a couple of weeks.

47. Sharon Butala, The Perfection of the Morning: An Apprenticeship in Nature

Over the weekend, I realized that I finished Sharon Butala’s The Perfection of the Morning: An Apprenticeship in Nature a month ago but didn’t post about it here. This short post is intended to address that oversight.

In 1976, Sharon Butala married Peter Butala, a rancher in the southwest corner of Saskatchewan, and left Saskatoon to join him there. She knew little about farming and nothing about the work of running a cattle ranch. The Perfection of the Morning is the story of how she came to love the rolling, treeless grassland at Old Man On His Back in the southern end of the Cypress Hills. When it was published in 1993, Butala was already an established novelist, and this memoir gained a wide audience. It’s a paean to nature, or to an ecosystem many people overlook or disregard, and to a way of living. It’s also a fish-out-of-water story, a true-to-life Künstlerroman, and a depiction of what amounts to a self-psychoanalysis, including dreams and visions. That combination gives The Perfection of the Morning its richness.

The writing, especially the descriptions of the land and of ranching, is beautiful. I open the book more or less at random, for instance, and find this:

On that day, on the far side of the hill in that slough-bottom, twenty or so cows stood grazing or lay with their calves beside them peacefully chewing their cuds. In their midst Peter’s saddle horse, reins dragging, browsed lazily too. And far off at the edge of the cluster of cattle, a couple of antelope stood, noses down in the grass. All of them were oblivious to my presence and paying no attention to each other, as if they were all members of the same contented tribe on that still, hot afternoon, under that magnificent dome of sky, in the midst of those thousands of acres of short, pale grass. About a hundred feet out from the foot of the hill, in the midst of his animals, head on one bent arm, hat shielding his eyes, Peter lay sound asleep.

Okay, I didn’t choose that passage completely at random; I stumbled across a later discussion of that moment and flipped backwards through the book to find this incident. Still, I love this paragraph: the patterns of sound, the evocation of place, the odd interspecies community of people, cattle and horses, and antelope. In 1996, the Butalas donated most of their ranch to the Nature Conservancy of Canada, and if you go to Old Man On His Back, about an hour’s drive west of Shaunavon, you’ll find a stone in a pasture, close to the road, marking the space where Peter took that nap. Watch for the bison, which now share the land with the antelope and cattle.

I first read The Perfection of the Morning in the 1990s, not long after it came out, as part of a comprehensive examination in Canadian literature. I loved it then, and now, after rereading it 30 years later, I feel much the same way. I’m looking forward to reading Butala’s subsequent volumes of memoir as well as her fiction. She’s in her 80s now, living in Saskatoon again, and still writing. In a quarter century, if I make it to her age, I hope I’ll still be writing, too.

46. Timothy A. Herwig, The Long Way Home

I’m going to be in conversation with Tim Herwig and Ann de Forest as part of a Walk-Listen-Create event in a couple of weeks (details will be forthcoming closer to the day it happens). We’ll be talking about my forthcoming book, Walking Well: Trails, Paths, Pilgrimages, and Herwig’s 2022 book The Long Way Home. My copy of The Long Way Home arrived last week, and I found a couple of hours to read it. Of course I’m biased–I love books about long walks–but I think The Long Way Home is brave, thoughtful, and lovely.

About 25 years ago, after a failed marriage and several years of subsequent unhappiness. Herwig decided to walk from Chicago, where he lived, to Minneapolis, near the town where he grew up. That 500-mile journey (I had no idea Minneapolis and Chicago were so far apart!) is the subject of the book. Herwig takes us along with him, giving us the sensory experience of the walk and portraits of the people he met. If that were all The Long Way Home did, I’d be happy reading it. But it includes something else.

Herwig was groomed and then sexually abused by one of his high-school teachers, an experience that haunted him, and as he walks, he shares more and more about that abuse with us. He doesn’t just relate the details, though. Somehow the act of walking 20 miles every day for weeks helps him heal the deep wounds he was carrying. Part of what Walking Well thinks about is the way that walking is good for our mental health, and I was happy to know I’m not the only person who has been able to let trauma go, at least a little bit, simply by walking. I wish I could understand the mechanism that allows that healing to take place. In Walking Your Blues Away, a short book I blogged about here 12 years ago, psychotherapist Thom Hartmann argues that walking is a form of bilateral movement, not unlike EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing Therapy), which has become a standard treatment for PTSD–even though nobody’s quite sure how it works. (EMDR’s inventor, Francine Shapiro, said she came up with the idea for this therapy while walking in a park.) Maybe that’s why Herwig found walking so helpful. Or maybe not: perhaps he felt better because he was spending time alone (his was a solo journey), thinking about what happened without drifting into unhelpful cycles of rumination. Perhaps it’s the way moderate exercise helps our brains produce BDNF, brain-derived neurotrophic factor, a protein that helps induce neural plasticity and create new connections between neurons. I wish more research were being done into this subject, but it’s not likely to make money for pharmaceutical companies (shoe manufacturers would be another story altogether). Anyway, the evidence that exists–some of it anecdotal, like Herwig’s book–suggests that walking is good for our emotional and physical health.

That’s not all that Herwig’s walk does for him. It also helps him connect with the world he’s walking through. “It does not matter that I am walking alone,” he writes. “I have made company with the land and the light that moves across it.” That connection gives Herwig the courage to begin re-creating himself (as a nun he meets, Sister Donna, suggests to him). Part of that re-creation involves telling us about the abuse, emerging from its heavy cloud of shame. Through the experience of his walk, Herwig begins to tell a new story about his life. At the party celebrating the walk’s conclusion, he tells us, “I have another beer and declare my love for everyone present, joyous in the peace I have found in a landscape of love in which I am now free to live.”

Well, I guess that’s kind of a spoiler, but I’m not sure how to talk about the transformative power of Herwig’s walk without indicating how he was transformed. As with other examples of travel writing (or og writing about long walks), part of the point of this book is to read his detailed account of the day-to-day experience of walking through the American midwest. Even without the narrative of recovery from trauma, this book would still be worth your time and attention.

44. John Burnside, Black Cat Bone

I picked up a copy of John Burnside’s Black Cat Bone because it’s referred to in Pat Collins’s film Silence, and I was curious. Even though he published five novels, seventeen books of poetry, and three works of nonfiction, our library has nothing by him. Perhaps he’s not well known, despite having won many prizes, including the T.S. Eliot Prize and the Whitbread Poetry Award. I loved this book, though, and I’m not sorry to have it in my collection.

There’s no wifi on this flight, so I was unable to translate the many quotations here (in German, Italian, and French), or check a dictionary for definitions of the often abstruse, archaic vocabulary. That’s fine, because it forced me to focus on the sound of the poems and their surprising images. I’ll admit that I don’t know what’s happening in at least half of the poems here, and that doesn’t matter. The multiple languages point to the importance of sound as much as sense, and I didn’t sense that Burnside was showing off his erudition. 

I couldn’t even be certain where the poems are situated. Some refer to North American things (cottonwoods, lodgepole pines), others to things I associate with Scotland (hedgehogs, kirks). The latter isn’t surprising, since Burnside taught at the University of St. Andrews until he died two years ago. Even the time when the poems are set isn’t always clear. The long poem that begins the book, “The Fair Chase,” for instance, seems to be set in the quasi-medieval world of some fantasy writing, except for the presence of firearms and the words “rotting tyres.” Those details don’t matter as much as the repeated figures and themes: lost love, death, mysterious shadows doubling the poems’ speakers, snow and winter. The book works by feeling rather than facts. I like that, selfishly, because I need more of it in my own writing.

I loved this, so much that I don’t completely trust my judgment. Perhaps a poet friend will let me know whether Burnside is as good as I think he is.